The Macbook Whine
Posted by Sam at June 17th, 2006
Some Apple customers who have purchased macbook pros have complained about a high pitched whine emanating from the notebook when the CPU is at or near 0 CPU load. I myself have this issue, and I can tell you it is ANNOYING. I found a small program that keeps a little load on the CPU and keeps the noise at bay.
This solution is almost enough except that I have to manually start it every time I reboot my computer. Also, every once in a while it will get out of hand and start eating major CPU cycles, making the notebook overheat and the fans kick on. Also, this hack eats into my battery life.
Apple has brushed off this issue saying the noise is “within spec” yet only have subjective tests to determine what the spec is exactly.
Point 1: The noise is fixed in new macbooks. If nothing was wrong why was it fixed?
Point 2: Apple engineers are old. It is a well documented fact that old people don’t hear high pitched noises as well as young people. Some stores in Europe even play high pitched noises to keep teenagers away, while the older people can shop unaware of any such noise. This leads me to believe that “within spec” just means that the old apple engineers simply think all us youngsters are crazy. We can hear the noise, loud and clear - and it’s annoying.
Point 3: So many people have complained. Forums are full of people complaining about this issue, yet Apple has been silent. One customer was told that “thats what he gets” for being an early adopter! Come on, Apple!
Point 4: The issue can easily be fixed with software. There are several hacks out that can eliminate the sound. Some are more questionable than the others, but the simple fact is that the CPU throttling software is flawed. It’ s not like Apple has to repair every single macbook, they can simply release a software update to fix this - it’s not even hard.
That’s all I have for now.



